Pick your Cake and Cupcake Flavors

CAKE or Cupcakes or both!

Cupcake tower with a 6″ round cutting cake on top.

It is time to pick your cake or cupcake flavors! Below is a list of cupcake flavor combinations we offer but first some info on our custom cakes, because we offer so many cupcake flavors combinations that can be used in our custom cakes and some are not available as cake flavors so check with us when you order.

Girly Girl Pink Cupcake
Girly Girl Pink Cupcake

For more information on our custom cakes go here Custom Cakes  We make cakes and cupcakes for every occasion big or small. Please be sure to order as far in advance as possible so that we can save the date on our calendar for you. Information about wedding cakes and wedding cake tastings can be found here.   Wedding page

Cupcake Flavor Collections

Yellow Rosebud Cupcakes

“The tastiest cupcake in Quincy is right here at Angela’s Baker Way Bakery! ” – A very satisfied customer

Cupcake sizes range from the Mini, Regular or Standard sized to Giant! If you can’t find a price listed for the cupcake you want please Contact Us! Minis are a 2 dozen minimum order and range from $8 – $12 a dozen. Regular sized Cupcakes are a 1 dozen minimum order if I am already filling orders that week and you want a flavor I am currently making I will accept half dozen orders. Pricing starts at $12 for a half dozen, $20 for a dozen cupcakes in our Classics collection to $36 for cupcakes in our Top Shelf and Tipsy Cake collection. Below is a list of cupcakes we make throughout the year. If you want to do some match making and design a cupcake of your own lets chat!  Availability of a flavor depends on the time of year and availability of fresh ingredients. Please Contact Us for more information or questions on our product! now for the fun part! let’s get this party started with our Top Shelf Cupcakes!

Top Shelf:

If you are looking for the best check out the Top Shelf! These cupcakes are filled, rolled, dipped and drizzled to beautiful cupcake perfection! We have 1 dozen minimum on this collection.

Banana Nut Sundae: Our delicious fluffy banana cake filled with strawberry sundae topping, topped with whipped vanilla ice cream flavored buttercream frosting, drizzled with Hershey chocolate syrup, edges rolled in sundae nuts and topped with a Maraschino cherry!

Trouble Maker: This cupcake is based on our signature cookie called the Trouble Maker. We start with white chocolate chips in our vanilla butter cake, fill it with salted caramel, topped the cake with chocolate buttercream frosting, roll the edges in crushed pretzels then drizzle more caramel over the top and sprinkle with mini chocolate chips.

Multi flavor cupcake tower with fresh flowers.

: You pick a vanilla or chocolate cake and we fill it with marshmallow cream, drizzle Hershey syrup over the cake, top it with toasted marshmallow flavored buttercream frosting, roll the edges in crushed graham crackers, and top with a square of chocolate Hershey bar and another drizzle of Hershey chocolate syrup.

Bananas Foster: We start with our fluffy banana cupcake, top it with our cheesecake flavored buttercream frosting and drizzle the top with caramel.

Cinnamon Roll: This cupcake is made with a swirl of our secret cinnamon roll spices in a vanilla butter cake and then dipped in our buttery cinnamon roll glaze and topped with a swirl of cinnamon cheesecake flavored buttercream frosting.

Naked Cupcakes
Naked Cupcakes

Chocolate or White Chocolate Raspberry: Pick chocolate or vanilla cake and raspberry or strawberry filling for this cupcake. We fill it with your berry of choice and cover it with a choice of chocolate or white chocolate and berry of choice half and half buttercream swirled frosting then place a fresh berry on top.

Dad’s Caramel Popcorn: This cupcake is a vanilla butter cake topped with a swirl of caramel buttercream frosting and topped with homemade caramel popcorn! This is a special cupcake. The caramel popcorn recipe has been a family favorite since I was a little girl. We would make an enormous batch for movies and Sunday afternoon snacks.

Cookie & Milk: You pick vanilla or chocolate cake and we cover it with Vanilla buttercream frosting topped with a fresh baked Chocolate Chip mini cookie.

Peanut Butter Cookies & Milk: You pick Peanut butter, chocolate, or vanilla cake. We cover it with your choice of peanut butter, chocolate, or vanilla buttercream frosting and top it with a fresh baked Peanut Butter mini cookie.

rainbow topped cupcakes with raspberry and white chocolate cupcakes

Cookies & Cream: You pick vanilla or chocolate cake and we bake a chocolate sandwich cookie in the bottom and top the cupcake with a scoop of cookies and cream buttercream frosting.

Pancake Breakfast: We start with a vanilla cupcake and cover it with a swirl of maple buttercream frosting and top it with a stack of maple syrup drizzled mini pancakes.

Cotton Candy: A berry vanilla cupcake is covered with blue raspberry flavored buttercream frosting and then topped with a puff of cotton candy.

Reg. sized cupcakes are $36 a dozen.

Fruit and Cream:

A delicious dreamy cupcake! Availability is limited depending on the time of year and the availability of fresh fruit. This cupcake is a vanilla cake filled with your fruit of choice filling and topped with a creamy fruit flavored buttercream that is whipped till fluffy!

Strawberries & CreamPeachs & CreamLemon CreamBlueberries & Cream

Raspberries & CreamOrange CreamBlackberries & Cream

Reg. sized cupcakes start at $24 a dozen


Light and tangy with a hint of summer in every cupcake. Made with a delicious twist of lemonade and fresh flavor in the cake and frosting.

Blue Raspberry Lemonade Cupcakes
Blue Raspberry Lemonade

Blue Raspberry Lemonade, Pink LemonadeRed Raspberry Lemonade, Strawberry Lemonade, Watermelon Lemonade, Peach Lemonade,

Reg. sized cupcakes start at $24 a dozen

Tipsy Cakes

This line was created as our featured cupcakes at Taste of Plumas in 2013 and has grown as customers have made requests. We use alcoholic drinks as inspiration. Our customers love the flavor twist. We are up to the challenge of creating a cupcake based on your favorite alcoholic beverage.

Winy Tipsy:

A little wine in your cake? All 3 wine cupcakes are  Angela’s Baker Way Originals!

Rose Wine and Chocolate: Chocolate cake with Rose wine baked in and buttercream frosting with a Rose Wine sweetened reduction mixed in for a truly unique cupcake.

Fruity Zin
Fruity Zin

Fruity Zin: A Vanilla cake flavored with a hint of red raspberry and topped with our fruity

Zinfandel buttercream and Zinfandel drizzle.

Spicy Zin: Spicy chocolate cake  and topped with our spicy Zinfandel buttercream and Zinfandel drizzle.

Tipsy Bartender:

Beer and Pretzels Mini Cupcake
Beer and Pretzels Mini Cupcake

Beer and Pretzels (X): A little Stout and some chocolate.

Guinness Chocolate, Baileys Irish Cream Frosting and Whiskey Ganache
Irish Cupcakes

Irish Car Bomb (X): Guinness chocolate cake, Jameson chocolate ganache filling and Irish cream buttercream frosting with more Jameson ganache drizzle.

Kahlua Chocolate: This one is super popular for wedding cakes. It starts with a Kahlua chocolate cake topped with our Kahlua chocolate buttercream frosting.

Drunken Banana: Banana and coconut rum cupcake with Caribbean Rum and pineapple buttercream frosting.

Margarita salted lime
Salted Lime Margarita mini cupcakes

Salted Lime Margarita: We start with a margarita lime cake and cover it with margarita lime buttercream frosting and top it with a small salted lime wedge. To eat this cupcake you squeeze the lime over the top and eat!

Raspberry and Lemon Drop Mini Cupcakes
Raspberry Lemon Drop Mini Cupcakes

Raspberry Lemon Drop:  This is a lemon cupcake topped with a swirl of raspberry vodka buttercream frosting and candied lemon peel.

Eggnog and Spiced Rum: Available November – December.  A spiced rum cake with a swirl of eggnog buttercream frosting on top.

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie: Available November and December only. This delicious cupcake begins with a chocolate Bourbon cake, filled with Bourbon pecan pie filling, covered with a swirl of butter pecan buttercream frosting, and topped with chopped candied pecans.

Bubble Tipsy:

Georgia Peach Mini
Georgia Peach Mini

Blue Raspberry & Champagne

Strawberry & Champagne

Georgia Peach: Peaches & Champagne

Red Raspberry & Champagne


Reg. sized cupcakes are $34 a dozen


This is exactly what you are looking for in a simple moist delicious cupcake. The Classics are timeless and season-less cupcakes. If you are looking for a simple delicious classic cupcake this is it.

Chocolate with Sprinkles
Chocolate with Sprinkles



Red Velvet

Birthday Cake

Vanilla with sprinkles
Vanilla with sprinkles






Reg. sized cupcakes are $20 a dozen

Nutty Bunch:

The nuttier the better! This line is a  delicious combination of flavors and nuts mixed in to the cake, buttercream frosting and covering the edges!


Vanilla Almond

Chocolate Hazelnut

White Chocolate Macadamia

Maple Pecan

Chocolate Toffee Walnut

Pralines and Caramel

Pralines and Cream

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Reg. sized cupcakes are $24 a dozen

Chocolate Collection

Something for every Chocoholic!

Chocolate Hazelnut
Chocolate Hazelnut

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Chocolate Covered Cherry

Triple Chocolate

Chocolate and Salted Caramel

Chocolate Banana

Chocolate Raspberry

Chocolate Orange

Pumpkin Spice and Chocolate

Rocky Road

Chocolate Chip

Reg. sized cupcakes are $24 a dozen


This list can change and has room for variation based on your preferences.  For every season we have a cupcake. We have a cupcake for every holiday or event of the year. Some of these are only made during the holiday season so get them when they are out because when the season ends the recipe goes back in the vault till next year.

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes
Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes

Pumpkin Spice: Available October 1 to December 31.  A pumpkin spice cupcake covered with cheesecake or maple flavored buttercream frosting and dusted with cinnamon spice.

Maple Cream: Available October 1 to December 31. Our maple flavored cupcake with maple cream buttercream frosting and topped with a maple syrup drizzle.

Churro: Our vanilla butter cake is baked with a cinnamon spice crust on top and then topped with honey vanilla flavored buttercream frosting.

Chocolate Peppermint: Available in December only. Chocolate cupcake covered with chocolate buttercream frosting and rolled in crushed peppermint candy.

Caramel Apple
Caramel Apple

Caramel Apple: Available August 1 to October 31. Our delicious apple cake made with fresh apple covered in a swirl of caramel buttercream frosting and drizzled with salted caramel.

Carott Cake Cupcakes
Vernetta’s Carrot Cake Cupcakes

Vernetta’s Carrot Cake: Available March, April, and November or by special order. This  cupcake is made from a special carrot cake recipe in my collection and covered in a cheesecake flavored buttercream frosting. Vernetta Allen’s cooking was famous in the area I grew up in. She taught cooking and homemaking classes to the girls in our town for many years. I think you will love this cake as much as I do.

Vanilla Chai Latte: A delicious vanilla chai tea spiced cake with a swirl of chai flavored buttercream frosting and topped with a dusting of cinnamon spice.

Sweet Potato Maple Nut: Available November – December. We start with a sweet potato cake and cover it with a swirl of creamy maple or toasted marshmallow buttercream frosting and roll the edges in chopped candied pecans.

Holiday Gingerbread: A gingerbread cupcake topped with a swirl of gingerbread or cheesecake flavored buttercream frosting.

Peppermint Mocha: Chocolate mocha cupcake covered with a swirl of peppermint mocha buttercream frosting and topped with a peppermint candy.

Apple Pie: This delicious cupcake starts with a spice cake that is filled with apple pie filling, covered in a swirl of  fluffy vanilla ice cream flavored buttercream frosting and topped with a hugs and kisses pie crust cookie. For a summery twist change the filling to raspberry, strawberry, cherry, peach, or blackberry.

Because these are seasonal and ingredient prices fluctuate please Contact Us to check pricing.

The Toy Box

Honey Dukes Pink Candy Floss Cupcakes
Honey Dukes Pink Candy Floss Cupcakes
Circus Cupcakes & Sprinkles Cake
Circus Cupcakes
& Sprinkles Cake

Tie Dye:

Holiday Sprinkle

Candy Bar topped

Butterfinger Cupcakes
Butterfinger Cupcakes

Colored Sugar Roll

Fondant face


Pink Birthday Cupcakes
Pink Birthday Cupcakes

Based on what you choose from the Toy Box and the time needed to design some of the fondant toppers please call for pricing.

Share this page